Reconstructing
Disability in Our Christian Thinking:
When I was a small boy visiting
some temple streets in India, I saw a mentally challenged person in chains in
front of his own house. Differently able persons in India are in many ways at
difficulties though a number of Christian schools have helped in one way or the
other. Deaf and Dumb schools are the most popular ones along with mentally
challenged schools run by the churches. In Hindu thoughts, I would think that
an idea of rebirth can be another haunting concept for a few families who are
struggling with a differently able child or young person as one of their
siblings. My own sister has given our family an experience that can be a
learning point for me and for others too.
But I have to ask frankly a few
questions which I do not have answers but will struggle with them. My first
question is whether I can write on behalf of differently able individuals or
groups. I do not think that I can write at all on neither their behalf nor
pretending to understand their struggles and pain. This article is an attempt to
highlight recent issues in Christian thinking, particularly making a case for
‘caring’ as a mandate rather than an optional Christian choice to choose in
order to follow Jesus Christ.
My second question is again a
struggle between two issues: first, the questioning of any norms or image of
being perfect or complete or accepted practices or established worldviews or
ideal human being and the second, aspirations for completeness or making life
better or content view or perceiving incomplete as complete in itself or
personhood in different limelight. A blind person can aspire to see the world
and so science and technology can facilitate such aspirations. Another blind
person thinks that he or she can never see this world and is content with what
he or she is. Possibly he or she does not want to see the world any more but
wants others to understand their world of perfection as they share or accept
the world as it is rather than try to change it. So my question is not simply
dismiss a person who is aspiring for completeness according to human standard
while recognising the fact that there are a few others who would accept their
realities as they are and would explore and see a completeness within their own
world. The second group may even question about the ability of those who assume
themselves a complete and may argue that some of them may be less able to use
one of their faculties in their body than the differently able person. This raises an interesting question about what
is a full or normal human being? Or one may ask it in another way how do people
perceive one as a simple and normal human being?
Bible and Disability
Bible teaches us that every human
being is created in the image of God.
If
we started using the Biblical versus selectively we will end up with many
questions and many troubled versus in the Bible. We have to make clear a few
points from the Bible – one is some versus in the Bible are either negative or
reflect the cultural views of those days religiously and negatively. They were
clearly uninformed hierarchical or problematic and ignorant views about
disability. Some people may not have even an experience of a differently able
person as one of their siblings or in their family and so simply making a
statement in the community for others with selective simplified information or
experience. So this reveals a stereotypical view of differently able that are
not very different from some attitudes and views today.
In
Leviticus
21:18-19 it is stated, “
For no one
who has a blemish shall draw near, a man blind or lame, or one who has a
mutilated face or a limb too long, Or a man who has an injured foot or an
injured hand,”. It is understandable if one imagines one’s context at the time
of Leviticus. If anyone questioned it, it would have led to great punishment. But
this verse reflects an attitude towards differently able people by the general
religious community during the time of Leviticus. But little later, King David
has brought one of the Saul’s sons – Jonathan was given a privilege of eating
with him. (2 Samuel 4:4 ESV Jonathan,
the son of Saul, had a son who was crippled in his feet. He was five years old
when the news about Saul and Jonathan came from Jezreel, and his nurse took him
up and fled, and as she fled in her haste, he fell and became lame. And his
name was Mephibosheth.) The reason may be that King David wanted to respect his
predecessor and God’s anointment of Saul through Samuel. So the circumstances
have made the difference in someone’s life that does not allow us to generalize
about the attitude and treatment of differently able person by the Biblical
Communities.
We also have a few other texts where we face
the question of how differently able individuals are born. Exodus 4:11 ESV Then the Lord said to him, “Who has made man's mouth? Who makes him mute, or deaf, or
seeing, or blind? Is it not I, the Lord? This passage makes the whole picture very
difficult. Professor John Swinton (Disability in Christian Tradition) asks this
question in relation to Psalm 139 where it states, “For you formed my inmost being.
You knit me together in my mother’s womb. Then it comes back to a general and
genuine question, Why God? Why did God allow this to happen? Why did God create
a person differently able person from his womb? Why did God allow a person to
be differently able? To add pain to this, we have a New Testament text too. John 9:2-7 ESV And his
disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was
born blind?” Jesus answered, “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents,
but that the works of God might be displayed in him. We must work the works of
him who sent me while it is day; night is coming, when no one can work. As long
as I am in the world, I am the light of the world.” How can the works of God might be displayed in
a different able person? Then when I ask this question, then I have a problem
with this question itself and my attitude is exposed. I would ask the question
in reverse why cannot I see the might works of God in the different able person
without being healed or restored or being fully human being? May be I can
expand the question a bit more by asking may be God’s mighty works might be
revealed through such persons more than what is accepted as a normal and
complete human beings. Is it a way to pacify my feelings or caring questions? I
think it is me, my view and my understanding are the problematic not the
differently able person’s incompleteness or perfect or normal human
personality. In my view I not only have serious problem with my understanding
of what is a normal accepted and perfect human being but also I face difficult
to accept the differently able person as perfect in himself or herself. I have
to reconstruct my own perception in this regard by accepting the way
differently able person wanted me to accept him or her. But the Biblical
passages that I mentioned above shape my attitude and view towards the
differently able person. We have to ask the questions but ask them by putting
ourselves into the mind and heart of a differently able person, then questions
become a way of learning and understanding - or at least it makes a beginning
towards changing our views, accepting the differently able persons as they are.
There are other views towards differently
able persons or at least one can interpret those versus in the positive light. Leviticus 19:14 ESV You shall not curse the deaf or put a
stumbling block before the blind, but you shall fear your God: I am the Lord.
Deuteronomy 27:18 ESV
“‘Cursed be anyone who misleads a blind man on the road.’ And all the
people shall say, ‘Amen.’
These versus clearly wanted to protect the
differently able persons from being misled or misguided by others. But these
versus do not promote a proactive or positive image of the differently able
persons as such. The prophetic books highlight generally the issue of justice
for all human beings. But I would like to highlight a few instances where God
is trying to use those who express to God their inability or disability to
carry on God’s mission. When Moses clearly told God that he cannot speak due to
faltering lips, the God responds saying I have made you like God over Pharaoh.
God emphasised clearly it was Moses who would do the job of liberating
irrespective of his faltering lips. (Exodus 6:30 But Moses said to the LORD,
"Since I speak with faltering lips, why would Pharaoh listen to me?"). Also in the calling of Jeremiah, God said he
would put words into the mouth of Jeremiah though he felt shy and expressed
inability to speak because he is young. In these entire passages one cannot use
the detective statement that the Old Testament has passages that can contribute
towards a stereotypical understanding of differently able persons. The views
vary and so the attitude. But when people began to look at the issue of justice
they might have asked the question about the justice for all including the
differently able person. These are particularly clear when it comes to the
question of God’s mission to those who felt they were not able to do it due to
their inability or disability. God did not give them up nor let them go away
from his calling in many instances.
New Testament and Differently able persons
Some of these passages are selected from the
Old Testament, but I wish to look at the New Testament as well. In the New
Testament we have similar views and understanding of differently able person
though a bit more matured than the Old Testament. Jesus asked his listeners to
invite a list of differently able person for a feast. Jesus often used the
image of feast as a point of bringing people together and making them to
realize that all are God’s children. Luke 14:12-13 ESV He said also to
the man who had invited him, “When you give a dinner or a banquet, do not
invite your friends or your brothers or your relatives or rich neighbours, lest
they also invite you in return and you be repaid. But when you give a feast,
invite the poor, the crippled, the lame, and the blind. Some of those who do
not have privileges are not only to be given privileges but also to be served
well by Christians. It is only through diakonia (service) and kenosis (emptying)
that Jesus ministry can be accomplished as a disciple. Such points emphasise
caring and serving with an idea that their Lord Jesus himself is caring and
serving.
Many of the gospel passages can be indirectly
interpreted in favour of caring, serving and loving the people with disabilities.
But there is a bigger issue here both of the Christological concept and also
its impact on doing something towards differently able persons. Some see this
as a compulsory option of following Jesus – a call or invitation that Jesus is
asking his followers to do. Such views have persuasive impact on many people
who feel that they are called to serve and love those who are differently able
persons. But the question arises when those who care begin to think that they
themselves need to care for their own and wanted to see serving, caring and
loving the differently able person as an option in their faith journey. This
implicates the theology of looking at God human relations where God wants human
beings to do something because human beings are indebted to God or because God
cares for them. What if someone begins to feel that they are not cared by God
and so should they care about someone who has disabilities. I will come back to
critique this theological position a bit later. Meanwhile I wish to highlight
that the second issue in the gospels is the miraculous healing of the
differently able person. Matthew 11:4-5 ESV And Jesus
answered them, “Go and tell John what you hear and see: the blind receive their
sight and the lame walk, lepers are cleansed and the deaf hear, and the dead
are raised up, and the poor have good news preached to them. These stories
complicate the approach to differently able person because they work on the
theme of healing as restoration and also as part of salvation. The questions
are restored to what? How many? Why not all? Why only selected persons? Jesus
himself faced this last question and did not answer it directly. For me healing
is not merely restoration rather it is a postponing of death or reducing the
pain of the individual person concerned or changing the attitude in a way that
gives strength to face such realities of life. Healing partially helps in the
case of deaf hearing and blind seeing which may prove that God is still active
in this world and also divinity of Jesus but does not restore his eye sight nor
his hearing for ever.
Eiesland
(1994:73-74) in his book, Disabled God, highlights three traditional approaches
in the Bible. First view relates disability with sin; second view combines
suffering with differently able person experience and the third view highlights
the differently able persons as objects of charity. He calls for disabling
theology itself. Some Biblical references can be interpreted in a way that
disability itself was seen as a punishment from God as a result of unbelief,
unfaithfulness and ignorance. (Jewish Encyclopaedia 1920). Some verses can be
interpreted as if disability was seen as a curse. (Proverb 30:17; Judges 14:2 –
Otieno in her article Biblical and Theological
Perspectives on Disability).
John Hull in his book Blindness
and Face of God, argues that some expressions such as ‘Blind’ are used in the
New Testament as a term of abuse or with negative connotations. For example, "blind guides"
(Matt.23: 16, 24), "blind fools" (v.17), and "you blind
Pharisees" (Vs.26). The Metaphoric use of differently able person’s
identity as a symbol of sin, unbelief and ignorance displays a moral approach
to the whole issue. Rayan in his article – Preparation of Bride, emphasises the
need for developing self-esteem, restoration of identity/recognition of identity,
restoration of society as three important approaches to the issues of
differently able persons.
Professor John Hull in his book Disability – The Inclusive Church
Resource writes about theology and disability very clearly and in simplified
ways. I like the approaches of denunciation and annunciation that John uses to
bring out his theology of disability. Denounce - the concepts of normality (he
refers to Amos Yong) what is normal (such as having an eye to see); complete or
restoration (include a critique of liberation theologies in this regard in
relation to differently able individuals) and language of seeing (challenges to
be more metaphorical than literal - even blind person can see in a metaphorical
sense). This language has created a lot of negative perception of blind people
- I once was blind but now I see (Amazing grace) - Blind cannot guide another
blind. He want to denounce such perceptions and language systems that creates a
negative perception of the differently able people! Announce - God is one who
understands the sign language; God is perfect but beauty and love makes him to
grow into more perfecting; God is one who withdraws his own power in order to
make room for others to exercise their freedom to speak; God's creation is far
from perfection and normality (though it was seen Good); In his sufferings and
death Jesus is seen as the disabled God.
Questioning Method/s
When I started a small initiative at UTC,
providing training to the mentally challenged young people in order to use
computers, I had undergone a transformation by taking risks – risk of
challenging existing attitudes and so the confrontation, risk of running into a
failure of a project or a programme or a training after a bit of investment and
also risk of initiating something without knowing what are we going to achieve
and really reaching the goals. But the young people who were trained at UTC IT
lab did not know how to write a full sentence nevertheless they were able to
type and play with icons easily. They showed a good progress to the surprise of
their own teachers. This gave them self-esteem as well. Whenever they left the
college they went with pride in their eyes and in their walk. I could see their
smiling face though in the beginning they were a bit worried about learning
computers. For theological students, this was completely something new, but as
they engaged with young fellows they loved training them and dedicated
themselves towards a better understanding of differently able persons.
Now let me question the methods in a
liberative reading of the Bible. Often we are told to deconstruct the
narratives from the perspective and experience of the margins. Such as task
involves raising questions about the accepted norms, narratives and practices
that are/were dominant in the society and were used by a particular group to
keep others- margins under control. In this method people at the margins are asked
to look at the dominant narratives with suspicion so that other meanings –
counter and secondary meanings could be identified that may help in the process
of emancipation. Even the secondary meanings can become dominant within as
other third and fourth level meanings are not allowed to be evolved within the
margins. Even the dominant voices within the margins can silence other meanings
that are trying to evolve in the name of liberation itself. For example when
the feminist voices have become dominant while black women voices were not
heard and so womenist voices have evolved. Now the Asian women also are trying
to find their voices heard in their own way. But then those who are struggling
with HIV/AIDS and the differently able are not heard within these voices of the
margins because many of their voices are just submerged or overwhelmed or
dominated by other liberative voices or even sidelined by other voices. People
have also become critical of wider inclusivity agenda due to range of issues
that they cannot include in every discussion or they have become too many to be
included. So the best way forward is to use a method which is to ‘reconstruct’
the texts that involves a hermeneutic of appreciation. It involves accepting
people as they are, not asking others to change and fit themselves into our
expectations or our norms or attitudes. This method also enables people to
appreciate the differently able people as they are, their different abilities
to contribute to their own and to others with excellence at times and even
taking humanity beyond their abilities. It also involves appreciating the level
to which they wanted to contribute and to which they are able to contribute.
This method questions many of the existing
practices of deconstruction as well. Because deconstruction can often lead to
reductionism in which a complete stereotyping of the any narratives or norms or
practices can happen. It means people select a few references in the Bible to
prove their point that the whole of the Bible is negative about the differently
able persons. Some may fight it hard to prove the other way by selecting
another set of references. Because in many people’s lives faith and religious
narratives cannot be negated nor be rejected, they wish to avoid the whole
question of deconstruction just because some of their methods wanted to throw
the baby with the bath tub. One is thrown to a situation of ‘Either/Or’ while
hermeneutic of appreciation as a method accept the reality that there are a few
references that have negative connotations, but focus mainly on those sub
meanings and sub texts that enable them to find their emancipation and also
provide them an identity. This process also involves recognition of the fact that
even the Biblical communities were not homogenous and struggled at times with
such issues in their own ways with the limited knowledge and resources
available for them those days.
So hermeneutics of appreciation involves the
appreciation of common spaces between me and those who are good only in using
some abilities. It is also appreciating their own spaces that they want to keep
to themselves which means some differently able persons wanted a recognition
that they are perfect in themselves in whatever condition they are in and also
be appreciated in the best abilities that they would like to display or use for
themselves and for others. There is a need to appreciate their own ways of
doing things and so appreciating as they are. It is also appreciating their
version of the world, their views of others and their faith and their
understanding though it does not rationally or meaningfully fit into what is
being accepted or normal. It is also appreciating their qualities of leadership
and their characters of exploring possibilities within and beyond their
abilities. In simple words we appreciate what they wanted to be and how they
wanted to be. In order to encourage them some of the common spaces may evolve
by appreciating the narratives that can give them a narrative platform from
their faith and historical narratives.
So the interaction between faith, reason and
experience can be one of mutually nourishing, appreciating, educating and
enabling the recognition of each individual as a contributory and non contributory
being within the community and community within and among communities. It
includes at times critical and creative engagement to become aware of the
dominating meanings, but then when one become exhausted with too many dominant
meanings, one may never discover the meanings that are relevant and important
for one’s own emancipation. And so some time one can use this method of
appreciation rather than going through the suspicion to reach to this state of
appreciation.
Using this method for differently able person
I wish to look at the Biblical narratives
again. Jesus himself had limitations in his communication that his disciples
and listeners were often misunderstood or misread his parables or sayings.
Jesus used the language of his audience and of his days but still was not able
to make everyone to understand his words. It does not show his inability rather
his listeners’ inability to grasp him. Those who tried to ask details and
questions came closer and even became followers. It is the inability of the
listeners that make Jesus could not succeed in his communication. This may be
the reason that Jesus told they have ears but do not listen, they have eyes but
do not see (Matthew 8:18). We had appreciated all the successful abilities in
Jesus that many of us did not have time to look the difficulties or inability
of Jesus in some contexts at particular time. We do not even look at it in
order to appreciate Jesus. In the same way because the community does not want
to recognise and use the other abilities of the differently able persons, the
communities fails to appreciate the other contributions and brilliance of the
differently able persons. It is the social structures, narratives; attitudes
and worldviews including religious concepts blind us and shut us down from such
appreciation. To come out of such blindness, it is not merely a critical
awareness of the dominant narrative but a creative awareness of the narratives
of differently able persons and their desperation for recognition and
appreciation that should be prima facto of our relationship with them.
The story of incarnation clearly points to
the inability of human to accept God of the Old Testament, righteous, just and
loving God and so God’s difficulties and inabilities to find a way to relate to
all human beings. When Jesus was raised from the death and ascended into
heaven, it also means he takes all our limitations and inabilities in him into
Godhood. The Trinitarian God as a community engages with each other accepting
and appreciating each one’s ability and disability within Godhood and mutually
appreciating and finding common space to grow their joy and peace within this
triune community and thus relate to human being welcoming them to join in this
triune community. Such a reconstruction of Godhood may also give us an image to
cherish in order to accept differently able person as they are and appreciate
what they able to contribute to themselves and to the community. In this
theological view, we see the differently able person as part of Godhood rather
than God and the other. This demands us not to view caring and serving not as
an option to follow Jesus but as an inevitable mandate for us to receive our
salvation in Christ and realize the meanings of our own lives because they are
part of discovery of our essential being in God. Without taking the differently
able persons seriously we cannot enter into the triune community to be part of.
As they are part of Godhood into which we enter, we recognise them as part of
our being itself and thus appreciate and care as if we are taking care of our
own body. This is why I argue that reconstruction as a method can enable us not
only appreciate and accept but to see them as we see ourselves in God. In order
to appreciate everyone in the community recognises the fact that everyone has
disabilities at times in some context. I can understand that this method can
raise many more questions than answer them but I have made a point in favour of
using reconstruction as a method. Let me end this with the quote from Jesus, (Matthew
25:40 quoting from a story) "The King will reply, 'Truly I tell you,
whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine,
you did for me.'